When an email campaign underperforms, it can be disheartening. You spent time crafting what you believed was the perfect message, but the results did not reflect your expectations. Whether it is low open rates, click-through rates, or conversions, a failed email campaign is not the end of the road. Instead, it is an opportunity to learn, adjust, and improve your future efforts. So, what should you do when an email tanks? Here are some steps to take to bounce back stronger.
Step 1: Dive Deep into the Metrics
The first thing to do when an email campaign underperforms is to analyze the data. Email marketing platforms provide a wealth of metrics that can help you understand where things went wrong. Here are some key metrics to consider:
- Open Rate: This tells you how many recipients opened your email. If your open rate is low, it could indicate that your subject line was not compelling or that your email landed at a bad time. Experimenting with different subject lines and sending times in future campaigns can help improve this metric.
- Click-Through Rate (CTR): This shows the percentage of recipients who clicked on a link within your email. If your CTR is low, it might mean that your content did not resonate with your audience or that your call-to-action (CTA) was not strong enough. Reviewing the placement, wording, and design of your CTA can provide insights.
- Conversion Rate: This is the ultimate measure of success—how many recipients completed the desired action, whether it is making a purchase, signing up for a webinar, or downloading a resource. A low conversion rate can suggest issues with your landing page, the offer itself, or the alignment between your email content and the landing page.
Step 2: Critically Review the Content
Once you have analyzed the metrics, it is time to review the content of your email. Was the message clear and engaging? Did you deliver on the promise made in the subject line? Content plays a critical role in keeping your audience interested and driving them to act.
Consider these aspects when reviewing your content:
- Clarity and Relevance: Was your message easy to understand, and did it address your audience’s needs or interests? Sometimes, we get so caught up in creative language that the core message gets lost. Ensure that your content is straightforward and relevant to your audience.
- Design and Layout: The design of your email matters just as much as the words. A cluttered or poorly designed email can be off-putting. Ensure that your email is visually appealing and that the layout directs the reader’s eye to the most important elements, like your CTA. Also, check if your email is mobile-friendly, as many users access their emails on smartphones.
- Call-to-Action: Your CTA is the bridge between your email content and the desired outcome. If it is not compelling, recipients will not take the next step. Reevaluate your CTA’s wording, placement, and even the button color. Is it clear what you want the reader to do next? Is there a sense of urgency?
Step 3: Conduct A/B Testing
After identifying potential areas for improvement, it is time to test your hypotheses. A/B testing, also known as split testing, allows you to compare different versions of your email to see which one performs better. You can test various elements, such as:
- Subject Lines: Test different subject lines to see which one generates a higher open rate. Try varying the tone, length, or use of personalization.
- Email Copy: Experiment with different versions of your email content. You could test a more straightforward approach versus a more creative one or try different levels of detail.
- CTA: Test different CTA wording, placement, or even the visual design of the CTA button. Sometimes, a simple change like adding urgency (“Buy Now” vs. “Learn More”) can significantly impact performance.
- Send Time: Testing different days of the week or times of day can help you determine when your audience is most likely to engage with your emails.
Step 4: Refine Your Audience Segmentation
Another crucial factor in email marketing success is audience segmentation. Not every email is relevant to every subscriber. By segmenting your list based on demographics, past behavior, purchase history, or engagement levels, you can tailor your messages to specific groups. Segmented emails often have higher open and click-through rates because they are more relevant to the recipient.
For example, you might send one version of an email to new subscribers and another to long-time customers. The content and offers would differ, as each group has different needs and familiarity with your brand.
Step 5: Learn, Adjust, and Move Forward
Even the best marketers experience campaigns that do not perform as expected. The key is not to see these as failures but as opportunities to learn and improve. After you have analyzed the data, reviewed your content, tested new approaches, and refined your segmentation, you are equipped with valuable insights for your next campaign.
So, when an email tanks, do not panic. Use it as a stepping stone to refine your strategy, and soon, you will see your efforts pay off.
Are you interested in turning underperforming email into a strategic advantage? CLICK HERE to find out how Inspire Media Group can help.
© 2024 Inspire Media Group